Ultimately, James Surowiecki (loooove the last name) has a couple of tons of claims but I think that his major claim is the outsourcing for the military is a bad thing because we aren't competing with any business, also that just because there is a private sector doesn't mean that things will get done more efficient or better. In the beginning he starts talking about oil and conspiracy theories, then as that builds up, towards the end he really shoot out about outsourcing saying that it can be effective, however, "doing things in-house is often easier and quicker."
His warrants that help him build his claim, are that companies are overcharging for oil because of the contract with the outsourcers, military used to rule itself and was interdependent until it began to outsource which wasn't a good idea because there main focus was war fighting and the outsourcers weren't going out on the battlefield.
I think his tone was very informative and persuasive. He didn't attack you with information, he swiftly presented it to you. Also he has this like build up of ideas which led to the ending which I felt was helpful because it was like a smooth read and everything led up to one another. He was very casual but then again very like tata, I know what I'm saying. He was like my favorite teacher, or my very smart friend, calm and informative, yet persuasive tone. Persuasive on what? Do it yourself!
Rhetorical function I would say again his thoughtful idea structure, the way he formed and placed his paragraphs. Its almost as if he wanted you to think you were doing one thing and then boom! Shots fired into your writing brain. Also I feel like he chose his facts very carefully and nothing was misleading.
His rhetorical devices were amazing. There was tons of logos, and then he had ethos because he gave dates, and he supported his ideas. Then he also qualified most of his claims with outsourcing how it can be effective but you have to have the right kind of company for it work. Then he said tons of witty quotes everywhere like, "do only what you do best, and pay someone else to do the rest." OR "the Army becomes a lean, mean killing machine, while civilians peel the potatoes and clean the latrines." Those quotes were clever and made you think like wow, or I can so get why you said that. Then he talks as if hes one of the military guys or hes in the loop with everything, "Last month, after two South Korean....." he uses last month as if its so casual, like him and I are just sitting down at the park drinking Starbucks. Loved it.
Nakijah, I appreciate your impulse to capitalize on your voice, but these sentences read like they're a bit out of control. Slow down. Focus. What is his major claim and what devices does he use to try to make it effective? Then you can walk us through the article and walk us through his argument and how he develops it.
ReplyDeleteBut give me your best writing here--you can't get better if you don't give it your all.